If you’re serious about oven-roasted meats, crispy veggies, or seared fish, a reliable broiler baking pan is essential. These high-heat pans make it easy to achieve restaurant-quality results at home — all while keeping mess and grease to a minimum.
In this review, I’ll cover 3 top-rated broiler baking pans from Amazon, personally reviewed and tested for performance, durability, and value. Let’s dive into the top picks for your kitchen.
1. GE Broiler Baking Pan – Nonstick Porcelain Coated
Overview:
This GE broiler baking pan features a nonstick porcelain-coated surface and a two-piece slotted design. It helps reduce grease while promoting even broiling. Ideal for meats, veggies, and small-batch baking under high temperatures.
Pros:
- Easy-to-clean nonstick finish
- Durable porcelain resists chipping and warping
- Great heat distribution for consistent results
Cons:
- Smaller size — best for single or couple servings
- May show light discoloration with frequent use
Best For:
Home cooks who want a dependable, compact broiler baking pan for quick meals and snacks.
- BUILT FOR THE BROILER: This broiler broiler pan for oven is made for broiling under high heat where typical pots will sh…
- BROILING TASTES BETTER: The design of this broiling pan for oven nonstick allows even heat circulation resulting in cris…
- DRAINS FAT: This slotted design of this broiler pan with rack allows fat to drip to the bottom pan so the food doesn’t c…
2. WB48X10056 Broiler Baking Pan – Heavy-Duty & Dishwasher Safe
Overview:
This durable broiler baking pan is made with high-quality porcelain-coated steel and is fully dishwasher safe. It’s large enough for family meals and strong enough to withstand regular use without warping.
Pros:
- Heavy-duty construction
- Safe for dishwasher and oven use
- Excellent for meats, fish, and hearty vegetables
Cons:
- Slightly heavier than others
- Coating may chip with metal utensils
Best For:
Frequent home bakers and broilers looking for a reliable, large-capacity broiler baking pan.
- DESIGNED FOR OPTIMAL ROASTING: roasting rack set holds food above the grid to allow air to circulate completely around a…
- CARBON STEEL COOKING PAN: provides a stable cooking surface while letting juices drain into the pan below.
- PERFECT SIZE LARGE PAN: 12-3/4 inches wide, 1-1/4 inch high and 16-1/2 inches long. The perfect size for most ovens.
3. Certified Appliance Accessories Broiler Baking Pan
Overview:
This sleek and simple broiler baking pan is built to withstand extreme heat (up to 1,000°F) and includes a slotted upper tray and solid bottom for catching drips. It’s a great budget-friendly option that still delivers solid results.
Pros:
- High heat resistance
- Easy-to-clean porcelain finish
- Lightweight and well-designed
Cons:
- No side handles
- Smaller surface area
Best For:
Those who want a sleek, no-fuss broiler baking pan that performs under pressure without breaking the bank.
- 2-Piece broiler pan & grill set made with heavy-duty, nonstick black porcelain measuring L: 16.5″ x W: 12.75″ x H: 1.75″…
- For use in electric or gas ovens for broiling and baking; can also be used for outdoor grilling.
- Replaces flimsy or heavily soiled broiling/baking pans, promotes healthier cooking by draining away fats, and is PFOA-fr…
Final Verdict: Which Broiler Baking Pan Is Right for You?
- For the best all-around nonstick option, choose the GE Nonstick Broiler Pan
- If you need a larger, durable pan for regular meals, go with the WB48X10056 model
- For a budget-conscious pick, the Certified Accessories pan delivers high heat performance at a great price
No matter your choice, each of these broiler baking pans brings something useful to the table — or oven!
Nicole’s Tip:
Let your pan cool before cleaning and avoid using metal utensils to preserve the porcelain coating. A little care goes a long way!